Call for a Custom Quote 608-687-7572 ext. 1

Turn your American Girl collection into cash

We pay top dollar for your unopened toys. Use our easy tools to submit a list of your toys to get a quote for your collection and get paid fast. It's quick and easy!

Default hero image

Your Current Quote: $0.00

Find your American Girl toys
Loader
Name Line Sub Line Upc Buy List
1999 Felicity's New Sister Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781562477622 $1.00
2-Doll Clothes Press Best Friend Dolls $1.00
2-Doll Colonial Carriage Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extras and Other Outfits for Dolls $1.00
2-Doll Colonial Carriage Best Friend Dolls $1.00
2000 Felicity's Dancing Shoes  Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584850311 $1.00
2001 Felicity Takes a Dare Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584852711 $1.00
2002 Felicity Discovers a Secret Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584854777 $1.00
2003 Kaya and the River Girl Beforever Historic Doll Collection Other Outfits and Extras for Dolls 723232057924 $1.00
3 Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Marie-Grace 540409701240 $8.00
A Playful Pup Beforever Historic Doll Collection Happy Birthday Molly $1.00
A Reward for Josefina Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781562477639 $1.00
A Surprise for Caroline Beforever Historic Doll Collection Bookstore for Girls 9781593698867 $1.00
Addy Doll & Hardcover Book Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Addy $1.00
Addy Doll & Hardcover Book Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Addy $1.00
Addy Doll & Paperback Book Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Addy 887961168761 $36.00
Addy Doll & Paperback Book Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Addy $1.00
Addy Studies Freedom Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584854807 $1.00
Addy's Hairstyling Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 550402428488 $3.00
Addy's Ice Cream Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Happy Birthday Addy 540409769769 $8.00
Addy's Little Brother Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584850335 $1.00
Addy's Plaid Summer Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540409796239 $10.00
Addy's Reading Poster Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy's Short Story Collection:Hard Cover - Addy Studies Freedom Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781593691226 $1.00
Addy's Short Story Collection:Hard Cover - Addy’s Little Brother Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy's Short Story Collection:Hard Cover - Addy’s Wedding Quilt Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy's Short Story Collection:Hard Cover -Addy’s Summer Place Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy's Short Story Collection:Hard Cover -High Hopes for Addy Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy's Summer Place Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 723232056972 $1.00
Addy's Sunday Best Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls $5.00
Addy's Wedding Quilt Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls 9781584852742 $1.00
Addy’s Accessories Beforever Historic Doll Collection Meet Addy $1.00
Addy’s Cape Island Dress Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 340407161301 $1.00
Addy’s Double Desk Beforever Historic Doll Collection Addy Learns a Lesson $1.00
Addy’s Flower-Picking Outfit Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540409641652 $5.00
Addy’s Kite-Flying Outfit Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540408762235 $17.00
Addy’s Nightgown Beforever Historic Doll Collection Night Time Extras 540409225876 $2.00
Addy’s Paper Dolls II Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy’s Party Treats Beforever Historic Doll Collection Happy Birthday Addy 540408073058 $6.00
Addy’s Patterns Beforever Historic Doll Collection Books and Extras for Girls $1.00
Addy’s Shoes & Socks Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540409268668 $4.00
Addy’s Stilting Outfit Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls $1.00
Addy’s Striped Dress Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540408171648 $5.00
Addy’s Trunk Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls $1.00
Addy’s Undies Beforever Historic Doll Collection Changes for Addy 540408083194 $5.00
Addy’s Washstand Beforever Historic Doll Collection Night Time Extras $1.00
Addy’s Work Shoes Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls $1.00
Adobe Oven & Bread Set Beforever Historic Doll Collection Changes For Josefina 740404101735 $5.00
Adorned Deerskin Dress Beforever Historic Doll Collection Kaya Shows the Way 540408624946 $8.00
African Dance Outfit of Today Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 824815332657 $5.00
After-School Outfit Beforever Historic Doll Collection Extra's and Other Outfits for Dolls 540408153408 $4.00