Call for a Custom Quote 608-687-7572 ext. 1

Turn your Lord of the Rings collection into cash

We pay top dollar for your unopened toys. Use our easy tools to submit a list of your toys to get a quote for your collection and get paid fast. It's quick and easy!

Default hero image

Your Current Quote: $0.00

Find your Lord of the Rings toys
Loader
Name Line Sub Line Year Series Manufacturer Upc Buy List
11" Poseable Eomer 35112812173 $1.00
111th Birthday Celebration Bilbo with Party Barrel The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2005 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112814412 $2.00
12" Lord of the Rings Figure: Gimli 35112811039 $2.00
1:24 Scale ARAGORN IN HELM'S DEEP ARMOR Battle Scale Figure - Lord of the Rings: Armies of Middle Earth Series 687203481500 $1.00
2003 - New Line / Play Along - Lord of the Rings : Armies of Middle Earth (Le Seigneur Des Anneaux0 - Moria Orc Bowman / Battle Scale Figure - Out of Production - Limited Edition - Collectible 687203481500 $1.00
2003 - New Line / Play Along - Lord of the Rings : Armies of Middle Earth - Aragorn in Gondorian Armor on Horse - Warriors & Battle Beasts - Battle Scale Figures - Out of Production - Limited Edition - Collectible 687203480176 $3.00
2003 TOY BIZ LORD OF THE RINGS THE TWO TOWERS WAVE 2 TRAVELING BILBO FIGURE HALF MOON PACKAGE 35112811688 $2.00
2004 - New Line / Play Along - Lord of the Rings : Armies of Middle Earth - Rohan Soldier Battle Scale Figure - Heroes & Villains of Middle Earth - Rare - Out of Production - Limited Edition - Colelctible 687203481845 $1.00
2004 - New Line / Play Along - Lord of the Rings : Armies of Middle Earth - The Legions of Haradrim Set : w/ Haradrim Warrior / Archer / Standard Bearer - Soldiers & Scenes - Battle Scale Figures - Out of Production - Limited Edition - Collectible 687203481654 $1.00
Aragon Armies of Middle Earth 2004 Heroes Play Along 68720348607 $1.00
Aragon as Strider the Ranger Sideshow Collectibles 12-Inch Figures 2002 Sideshow Collectibles 747720208193 $9.00
Aragorn NECA Statues 2004 NECA 634482305508 $1.00
Aragorn The Fellowship of the Ring 12-Inch Figure 2001 Toy Biz $1.00
Aragorn The Return of the King 2003 Series 2 Toy Biz $1.00
Aragorn The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2002 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz $1.00
Aragorn The Two Towers Basic Figure 2001 Series 3 Toy Biz 35112810636 $5.00
Aragorn (Battle Armor) & Brego The Return of the King Deluxe Horse & Riders 2003 Toy Biz 35112813767 $4.00
Aragorn (Helm's Deep) The Two Towers Basic Figure 2003 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112811886 $3.00
Aragorn (Helm's Deep) (Super Poseable) The Two Towers Basic Figure 2005 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz $1.00
Aragorn (King of Gondor) The Return of the King Basic Figure 2003 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112813224 $5.00
Aragorn Battle Action The Two Towers Basic Figure 2005 Red Package Series Toy Biz 35112815686 $3.00
Aragorn Council of Elrond The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2005 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112816317 $1.00
Aragorn Super Poseable with Sound Base The Return of the King Basic Figure 2004 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112815266 $2.00
Aragorn on Horse (Gondorian Armor) The Return of the King Figures with Horses 2004 Play Along 35112813361 $8.00
Aragorn on Horse (strider outfit) The Return of the King Figures with Horses 2004 Play Along 35112813767 $4.00
Aragorn on Horseback Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480084 $1.00
Aragorn with Brego The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz 35112811817 $18.00
Aragorn with Brego The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz 35112811817 $18.00
Aragorn with Real Arrow Launching Action! The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810636 $5.00
Armored Troll The Two Towers Electronic Figures 2002 Toy Biz 35112813415 $6.00
Army of the Dead Armies of Middle Earth 2005 Series 6 Play Along 687203480312 $14.00
Arrow Drawing Legolas Motorized Twist 'Ems 2004 Toy Biz 35112814276 $1.00
Arwen The Two Towers 12-Inch Figure 2002 Collector Series Toy Biz $1.00
Arwen (Blurry Photo) The Fellowship of the Ring 12-Inch Figure 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810537 $4.00
Arwen (Clear Photo) The Fellowship of the Ring 12-Inch Figure 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810537 $4.00
Arwen (light-up evenstar) The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2003 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112813903 $5.00
Arwen Special Collector Edition 35112811046 $3.00
Arwen and Asfaloth The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2003 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810919 $2.00
Arwen and Asfaloth (2-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figure 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810919 $8.00
Arwen and Frodo on Horseback Warriors and Battle Beasts 2004 Play Along 687203480060 $1.00
Arwen in Coronation Gown The Return of the King Basic Figure 2004 Movie Trilogy Toy Biz 35112813576 $6.00
Arwen with Authetically Styled Fabric Outfit and Accessories The Fellowship of the Ring Basic Figures 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810537 $4.00
Attack at Amon Hen Intelliblox Construction Set 2001 Playmates 43377409045 $3.00
Attack at Amon-hen Armies of Middle Earth 2003 Series 2 Play Along 687203481029 $2.00
Balrog NECA Statues 2006 NECA 634482304792 $41.00
Balrog - Earth JRR Tolkein's LOTR Basic Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault 651174010076 $2.00
Balrog - Fire JRR Tolkein's LOTR Basic Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault 651174010199 $1.00
Balrog - Fire (Blue box) JRR Tolkein's LOTR Basic Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault $1.00
Balrog - Forest JRR Tolkein's LOTR Basic Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault 651174010083 $1.00
Balrog - Khazad-dun JRR Tolkein's LOTR Basic Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault 651174010052 $2.00