Call for a Quote 608-687-7572 ext. 1

Turn your Lord of the Rings collection into cash

We pay top dollar for your unopened toys. Use our easy tools to submit a list of your toys to get a quote for your collection and get paid fast. It's quick and easy!

Lord of the Rings

Your Current Quote: $0.00

Find your Lord of the Rings toys
Name Line Sub Line Year Series Manufacturer Upc Buy List
Gandalf NECA Statues 2004 NECA 634482304600 $17.00
Smeagol NECA Statues 2013 NECA 634482304884 $10.00
Legolas NECA Statues 2004 NECA 634482305515 $5.00
Balrog NECA Statues 2006 NECA 634482304792 $41.00
Aragorn NECA Statues 2004 NECA 634482305508 $1.00
Legolas Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along $1.00
Gothmog on Warg Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480404 $3.00
Morannon Orc on Warg Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480220 $1.00
Warg Rider Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480107 $1.00
Legolas & Gimli on Horseback Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480053 $3.00
Pippin in Gondorian Armor with Gandalf on Shadowfax Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480206 $5.00
Gandalf the Grey Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along $1.00
Ringwraith Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480077 $2.00
Rohan Horseman Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480237 $2.00
Aragorn on Horseback Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480084 $1.00
King Theoden on Horseback Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480923 $1.00
Gondorian Horseman Armies of Middle Earth Single Packs 2003 Exclusives Play Along 687203480091 $2.00
Gollum Premium Format Figure Sideshow Collectibles Premium Format 2011 Sideshow Collectibles 747720216891 $1.00
Uruk-Hai Warrior vs.Gimli The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810483 $12.00
Arwen and Asfaloth The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2003 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810919 $2.00
Coronation Gift Pack The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2004 Toy Biz 35112814245 $10.00
Frodo & Samwise Gamgee The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810469 $7.00
Deluxe Gift Pack 9 Pack (without elven cloaks) (9-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2002 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810995 $27.00
Deluxe Gift Pack 9 Pack (with elven cloaks) (9-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2002 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810995 $27.00
Elves of Middle Earth - Prologue Elven Warrior - Legolas - Elrond of Rivendell - Arwen - Gil-Galad - Haldir (6-Pack) The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2005 Toy Biz 35112816553 $44.00
Pelennor Fields Gift Pack (5-Pack) (Soldier of the Dead - Legolas - Mumakil Rider - Gimli - Morannon Orc) The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2005 Toy Biz 35112816041 $14.00
Kings of Middle-Earth - Prince Isildur - King Elendil - King Theoden - Aragon King of Gondor - The King of the Dead - Morgul Lord Witch-King The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2004 Toy Biz 35112816577 $17.00
Battle at Shelob's Lair The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2003 Play Along 35112816508 $10.00
Frodo - Samwise - Bilbo - Merry - Pippin - there and back again... (5-Pack) The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2003 Toy Biz 35112813651 $11.00
Boromir vs. Lurtz (2-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810414 $5.00
Black Gate of Mordor - Legolas - Gimli The Mouth of Sauron with Steed - Aragon with Anduril Sword - Gandalf the White (5-Pack) The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2004 Toy Biz 35112814238 $1.00
Final Battle of Middle-Earth - Legolas - Pippin in Armor - Merry in Armor - Attack Troll - Aragorn - Gandalf (6-Pack) The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2004 Toy Biz 35112816904 $10.00
Ringwraith Gift Pack The Return of the King Multi-Pack 2004 Toy Biz 3511284641 $1.00
Pelennor Fields Gift Pack The Return of the King Multi-Pack Toy Biz 35112816041 $14.00
Merry and Pippin vs. Moria Orc (2-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Multi-Pack 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz 35112810421 $5.00
Cave Troll The Fellowship of the Ring Large Figure 2001 Green Package Series Toy Biz $1.00
Lothlorien Gift Pack - Haldir - Celeborn - Galadriel - Frodo - Aragorn (5-Pack) The Fellowship of the Ring Gift Pack 2005 Toy Biz 35112816034 $1.00
Aragorn on Horse (strider outfit) The Return of the King Figures with Horses 2004 Play Along 35112813767 $4.00
Aragorn on Horse (Gondorian Armor) The Return of the King Figures with Horses 2004 Play Along 35112813361 $8.00
Armored Troll The Two Towers Electronic Figures 2002 Toy Biz 35112813415 $6.00
Ringwraith & Horse The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz $4.00
Aragorn with Brego The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz 35112811817 $18.00
Sharku & Warg Beast The Return of the King Deluxe Horse & Riders 2003 Toy Biz 35112813385 $8.00
Aragorn with Brego The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz 35112811817 $18.00
Gandalf the White & Shadowfax The Two Towers Deluxe Horse & Riders 2002 Toy Biz 35112811824 $9.00
Fell Beast & Ringwraith The Return of the King Deluxe Horse & Riders 2003 Toy Biz 35112814801 $19.00
Aragorn (Battle Armor) & Brego The Return of the King Deluxe Horse & Riders 2003 Toy Biz 35112813767 $4.00
Legolas & Horse The Return of the King Deluxe Horse & Riders 2003 Toy Biz $1.00
Lord of the Nazgul - Black Captain (No cape, Alternate weapons) JRR Tolkein's LOTR Deluxe Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault $1.00
Lord of the Nazgul - Black Rider (Cape) JRR Tolkein's LOTR Deluxe Figure 1998 Middle Earth Toy Vault $1.00